Japanese Hip Hop; a Homage or an Infatuation, resulting in cultural appropriation?

BCM111, Communication and Media

Hip Hop is a music genre which originated in the Bronx, New York in the 1970s and since its inception has grown exponentially becoming one of the most popular music genres globally. This, in turn, has lead to Hip Hop being adapted and localised to different parts of the world but, has also lead to very controversial instances of appropriation of black and Hip Hop culture. Including, lyrical, fashion and dance appropriation.

Cultural appropriation involves taking or adopting elements of one culture, typically without their permission and implementing them into another culture. This becomes particularly controversial when the original cultures values or origins are not acknowledged or respected by the adopting culture. 

In Japan, Hip Hop can be deemed significantly controversial as it is hard to determine where to draw the line of what is paying homage to the origins of Hip Hop and supporting the political messages that it is used to convey. Or, where their ‘support’ becomes cultural appropriation that stems from a lack of knowledge, racism and insensitivity (Tai, 2018).

Hip Hop as a culture is seen as an anti-establishment force, fighting for black rights in America. Whereas, Japanese Hip Hop can take an extremely nationalist or even racist tone. Initially, Hip Hop was seen as embodying not only the ‘black experience’ but the ‘physical black body’ (Thomas, 2016), which introduced B-style; dreadlocks, braids, jewelry and some would even go as far as darkening their skin to mimicry Hip Hop’s culture (Tsadwa, 2016).

Image result for japanese hip hop cultural appropriation

Japanese B-style. (Tsadwa, 2016).

For some of the B-style orientated Japanese personalities, this evolved into an obsession with the whole Hip Hop culture;

‘At one point, I wanted to be black so badly, so badly . . . But, you know, it’s impossible’

Stated Zeebra, a legend figure within the Japanese Hip Hop scene (Zeebra, 2008).

‘(I) copied their every move – from the way they greeted each other, the way they walked, even to the way they smoked’ 

Another example, from Hiro a Japanese Hip Hop pioneer (Hiro, 2005).

These infatuations have caused others to claim ‘Blackness’ has been fetishised by the Japanese Hip Hop community. They also have developed a sort of unofficial list of goals that embody what it means to be black, in Japan. With men remolding themselves into Hip Hop style and women also obtaining the Hip Hop style, as well as, an African American “lover” (Cornyetz, 1994, pp. 115). This raises issues of cultural appropriation as none of these goals or attempts to embody Hip Hop culture do not acknowledge or pay respect to Hip Hops origins or the political issues that they stand for.

Image

Event renamed after receiving controversy for the original name ‘Life of Niggaz’, follow on twitter.  

There are also issue that can arise from the Japanese use of the controversial terms ‘Nigger’ and ‘Jap’ within their culture claiming they are the “same” urging there is ‘brotherhood’ in ‘victimhood’ (Thomas, 2016).As both terms were originally used as a suppressive vice and have now been transformed as a means of self-empowerment, to be used exclusively by their own cultures. Therefore, when the Japanese Hip Hop groups claim they have the same rights to the term as African Americans have, many issues can arise as their infatuations can hang onto many damaging stereotypes and disregard the real connotations that, ‘that’ world can carry and the damage it can potentially inflict.

 

 

Reference List;

Scholarly Articles;

Other References;

Advertisements

One thought on “Japanese Hip Hop; a Homage or an Infatuation, resulting in cultural appropriation?

  1. Thanks for citing my piece! I think you did good research and gave me some new information.

    If you dig any further into the topic, I’d suggest treating hip-hop music with more nuance. Not all hip-hop music is highly political. In fact, most of it isn’t! That being said, you defended the culture well. I also ask that you consider Japanese fans of hip-hop don’t have as many accessible reference points (i.e. Black people) as non-Black Americans have when they participate in hip-hop culture. It’s tricky to get emulation and cultural exchange right from such a great cultural and physical distance, even with social media. I think the case of Japanese hip-hop culture is one where compassion and constructive criticism can be highlighted as important parts of good cultural exchange.

    -Zander, Across The Culture

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s